Comments on the P51

1/12 scale P51

Pocket P51

Pocket P51 slope conversion

 

Josh Huber of Portland, OR sent this 10/17/06;

  I bought a P51 D combat plane awhile back, and wanted to say thanks.  This is the funnest plane I've ever flown, and so fast.  It took awhile to get used to the speed, but I soon (5 or 6 crashes later) got the hang of it.  This plane was fun to build, the instructions along with the web site were more than adequate for a first-time foamie builder.  I piled it straight into the ground at top speed at least 3 times, and it took more time to go pick it up off the field than to replace the prop and get it back in the air.  Fellow pilots were also amazed at how well it flew, even in strong winds, and how indestructible it was.  After a gallon and a half of fuel and 5 props, a fence post finally got the best of her.   So I just bought another P51 D from your shop, and will be in the air in no time.  Thanks again

        Josh Huber
        Portland, OR

We're so glad you got the picture before it met the fence post

 

 

Why do you have a picture of a BF109 under the Mustang page - you ask!? Well Brian Woolsey sent us this picture of a kit bashed P51B that he turned into the 109. Mighty nice morph job - wouldn't you say? 

 

 

Flew the P51 Sunday afternoon. With the ailerons in the correct position and with some added downthrust it really picked up some speed!!  I started working on the combat moves and was having a great time!!  I then got a "wild hair" and came across the field inverted at full throttle about 10 feet off the ground. It was pretty cool!!  Well, I got "jelly brain" because I pulled "UP" in relation to the plane instead of in relation to the earth!! The resulting sound of that P51 hitting the ground was impressive to say the least. Luckily, the field was soft from all the rain. The plane went into the ground up to the wings (vertically of course). It then started to cart wheel across the field. I thought for sure the plane was toast. To my amazement, though, the only damage was to the left wing (cracked one spar and slightly twisted). Easily repaired! I went back to look at the point of impact just to make sure there weren't any pieces missing I wasn't aware of. This is when it hit me! I've re-invented the Post Hole Digger!!!   Now if only I could "plant" it at 8' intervals...   Anyway, I've already got it cleaned back up and the glue is drying. It should be flight ready in a day or two.

  Thanks,

Dave

 

Sent:                      Tuesday, June 10, 2003 12:25 PM  

Subject:                 P51 Photo

 

I thought you might like to see one of your P51's done up in silver mylar with conversion to electric power.  I used a JETI brushless motor (15-3), a 9-6 folding prop and seven-cell 1200 SCR batteries. With this setup I could fly acrobatically for 6 to 7 minutes.  The best part was the vertical performance--she could be hand launched straight up and out of sight in 30 seconds.

 

Alas, she is no longer with us.  I forgot to reverse the elevator servo after flying another plane.  Her end wasn't painless, but it was mercifully quick.

 

Thanks for a great flying and easy to build product.

 

Justin Revenaugh

 

Thanks for the details on your electric conversion of the P51. Nice looking plane Justin!

Ever wonder what "Captain Nemo" does in his spare time?!?!--------
He flies foamie combat, of-course! Bob (Ace) Conrad sent us these photos of his P51 all decked out in invasion trim and silver tape. His other passion is scale submarines and this is an excellent rendition of the Nautilus. Ace says it will dive to 30 feet, has onboard ballast control and full cabin lights. Both models are a testament to his modeling abilities, wouldn't you agree!?

John modified the Pocket P51 and converted it to electric - this is how he did it.................

re: electric Pocket p-51

Well, it worked . . .

The primary deviation from the instructions was in the wing assembly.  Instead of fiberglass straping tape, I added a carbon fiber tape strip top and bottom. (sold by Dave Brown products--1" wide, looks like black ribbon from a birthday present)

The wing is as stiff as a 2 by 4!  No flex, no buckle.   WOW!

Parts used: 

Hitec 555 mini receiver.

Cirrus CS-10 sub-micro servos

Aveox a-15 speed control

Speed 400 6v motor

7x600ae battery

APC 5.7X3 prop

I started with a 7 cell 600ae pack, and a speed 280BB motor...  It flew, but with the added weight it had to fly FAST...  The speed 280BB barely had enough power to keep it aloft.  SO, I upped it to a 6v speed 400 w/ a 5.7X3 APC prop.  Still kept the 7 cell pack.  It flew fairly well, although you cannot take it below full-throttle.  Loops and rolls were responsive, but it had an annoying tendency to roll and tailspin if the elevator were pulled up too hard. 

After reading your instructions from the 1/12th scale p-51, I installed a stall strip, 4" on each wing at the root, fashioned from a piece of triangle stock.  It was amazing the stability this trick brought--Thank You!...

The plane flew, and flew FAST, but had a tendency to stall when landing.  (Yes, I had about 4 good crashes--destroyed the speed 280--before I figured out what was wrong--the plane is still in great shape.   Anyway, my conclusion is that the wing area is too small for electric conversion.  If, however, you had a NON-symmetrical wing, something with some good lift, I'd bet it would fly beautifully. 

John Sawyer

Then he made some changes..............

I finally went out and cut a new wing.  Specs:  Clark-y, 7" X 11.38% thick at the root, 4" X 10% thick at the tip.  Overall length: 28". I ran 8 600ae cells, 6v speed 400 and the cheapo gunther prop (same one that Zagi uses on their planes). Result:  It rocked!  Great roll-rate, loops, etc.    It still flew very fast and was very stable.   Landings were a bit hairy, but I found if you come in hot, and keep it on the deck, it slows down eventually and lands well. I am SOOOOO happy with the plane, once I cut the new wing.  It still tip-stalls at low speed, but if you're gentle on the elevator it still handles well. Thanks for the great kits...John Sawyer

Tee sent this picture to us of his Pocket P51 - panel lines and everything, nice detail!

1/12 scale P51

Ron sent this note and pictures.............

Hi, I just flew the P51 foamie that I purchased from your company.  I just want to to tell you I had a blast.. I made a few modifications to the original design;

First, Instead of using two or three strips of strapping tape on the bottom of the wing I covered the entire wing top and bottom with 1-1/2 strapping tape.  Second instead of using the coroplast ailerons I used balsa ailerons stock, I also installed internal aileron control rods for a cleaner look.. I am using a O.S. 25 FP in the plane, Its a rocket, I saw it do something that freaked me out.  I did a split S maneuver (going inverted and pull up elevator) I was at full throttle, when the plane came down in the high G inverted turn I saw the wings bend almost in a V shape. I was glad I used all that strapping tape.  When the turn was complete the wing straightened out and I came in for a super high speed pass when the plane was in front of me I pulled hard up elevator. The plane shot vertical in almost its own length. It was an awesome sight. One note, in the instructions it called for ¼" throw on the ailerons, I found it was way to much. I used the duel rate at 45% on the ailerons and the elevator. This is the first plane that I ever had to belly land, so my first couple of landings were less than perfect, the first was cart wheeling wing tip to wing tip.. but the plane had no damage at all. Everyone at the field was amazed at the performance of this plane. I have enclosed a couple of pictures of my P51-D

Thank you , Ron M

 

Dick Monson sent us a picture and some comments about his Electric, speed 400 - P51.......

Hey Guys: I’m the guy from Salem that bought your Mustang at Washugal and you sent it to me a few days later, remember? Finally got it built and it flys great. For me, fast enough to keep me on my toes. Iv’e attached a picture. Other than a few strips of tape in strategic places, it’s covered in Silver Solarcoat. I also wish to order a T52 Trainer ……..

Thanks, Monson

 

Mike writes:

Hey guys! I may have written you before on this but Your p51 is JUST THE BEST!!!!!!! I have been building and flying planes for over 20 years and I cannot believe the fine flying characteristics of the planes you sell for so little money! I put a Speed400 with a mini Olympus on mine. It is so quick and responsive I can fly the thing within an inch of my head at full speed and have a sense of total control. Can't tell you how much fun I am having! Sincerely yours,   Mike Anticoli

 

Randyl  Britten sent this picture and some comments on construction you might find interesting if you intend to make an electric P51

My electric combat P-51 project based on your 1/12th scale foamie has turned out very well, thanks in very large part to you guys. An image file is attached as P51ME2.jpg.

I started out with every intention of building it by your instructions, except where necessary to adapt it to electric. However, it did not quite turn out that way.

Shaping the foam fuselage was very easy. I used emery coated metal shaping tools I got at the Puyallup Expo, and sandpaper. Used with a light touch, these tools cut quickly and easily, and did not clog up. Cutting interior space in the fuselage also went well using a long, sharp exacto-type blade and a light sawing motion. I tried the serrated grapefruit knife without much success. The foam tended to ball up under the blade. I guess my grapefruit knife was too dull.

I tried to add lightening holes to the coroplast tail parts, but the rotary saw drill blades left ragged edges that were not easy to get smooth. After covering, the rough edges of the holes were still visible. In future I would much prefer to use balsa tail parts for the sake of appearance, and I do realize that they would not be as durable. After adding the coroplast doublers on the fuselage sides, covering with the packing tape supplied went about as expected. It was impossible to avoid some bubbles and wrinkles, but it did not seem to matter a lot by that time. Okay, the fuselage is not a pretty piece of work.

At that point I set the project aside for a few days, and somehow the remainder of the coroplast accidentally got discarded with the scrap. Because of that I ended up using ¾ inch balsa ailerons. The wing turned out very nicely with no wrinkles, except at the compound curves on the wingtips. I used scrap foam to make the leading edge fairings that are a distinctive feature of the P-51 and adds a lot to the scale-like appearance.

The electric power went in easily. I used an Astroflight Brushless 02 with an Astroflight Superbox reduction gear, powered by seven 1100 MAh cells from SR Batteries. This is a fine, lightweight e-power combination that I have used very successfully for over two years in an electrified Airtronics Q-Tee. Both the Q-Tee and the foamie P-51 weigh in well under two pounds with about the same wing area and wing loading. I deliberately stacked the deck for a successful flyer by using this power train. The prop is a Kyosho 9x8 for electrics.

I used light ply to make the bulkhead mounted on the front of the fuselage block between the coroplast doublers. A one inch hole saw was used to drill through to the central interior space. The inside space for the battery pack was adjusted until the CG was in the right place. A short piece of cardboard tube, left over from a roll of Micafilm, glued to the bulkhead completed the light weight motor mount. The Astroflight Brushless 02 motor, less than one inch in diameter, and its integrated electronic speed control, fit easily and mounted securely with rubber bands and mounting tape.

The cowl is made from a two liter plastic soda pop bottle. I carved a plug in the shape of the P-51 nose from another piece of two inch foam block, and shrank the pop bottle to the plug with a heat gun. This is a popular and inexpensive way to make cowls, canopies, and other durable, light weight model parts. The pop bottle material can be shrunk about 30% with high heat. Plugs can be carved in the desired shape from hardwood or foam block.

I used two FMA Direct S-100 micro servos for the elevator and ailerons. The elevator servo mounted cleanly just behind the cockpit canopy. In a future version I will try an interior mounting to clean up the appearance. When it came to shaping the cockpit canopy I decided I’d had enough of the packing tape wrinkles on compound curves. After shaping the foam canopy with the emery boards I covered it with a layer of Model Magic filler, and sanded that down again to its final shape. Then I used Testor’s gloss white spray paint and trim tape to finish it for scale appearance. The rest of the model was spray painted with Testor’s metallic silver. Testor’s spray cans are the ones to use with no problems and can be used directly on the foam. Most other spray paints will attack the foam.

This model is decorated as the ME-2, or Me Too, the second member of my growing P-51 squadron. It has several flights by now and flies very nicely. It hand launches easily and climbs out at an aggressive angle. With power off, and thanks to the light wing loading, the P-51 easily glides a long way before settling gently into the grass. I have not yet pushed flight duration to its limits. Its longest flight so far has been six minutes, and still had plenty of power when it landed.

It does not exactly tear up the sky, but it is plenty fast for me thanks to its clean low drag lines. I’ve been calling it my combat trainer. It loops and rolls easily and can change direction very fast. The Me Too is a load of fun and I definitely plan to build another one, and put just a little more power in it. The brushless 02 is just not enough power to be competitive with the gas guys. But I have an Astroflight Brushless 05 just waiting for the ME-3...

Specification As Built Actual P-51D Variation from

1/12 Scale------------- -------- ------------ --------------

Span 38.5 in 37 ft 4%

Root Chord 9.5

Tip Chord 6.25

Average Chord 7.875

Wing Area 300 sq in

Weight 28 oz

Wing Loading 13.3 oz/sq ft

Length 33 in 32.25 ft 2.3%

C. Randyl Britten

Software Engineer

Gasboy Development

 

Dave West
We received this letter and picture (left)  from Dave West and thought you might like to see it.....
Jim,
I thought you might like to see the attached image of my JK Areotech Mustang. It is done in British markings using brown packing tape and low temp Easy Cote for the green camouflage.
With OS .15 power, I have used it in several 1/12 scale combat events (including the NATS in Muncie). I had to make a few changes to bring it within the scale requirements of the RCCA rules. I added ½ inch foam doublers from the nose to just behind the wing to add a total of one inch to the fuse width. This also added strength, making up for the large hole I made to accommodate a 4 oz fuel tank.
I increased the taper of the wing a bit (although it is still too wide at the tips). I also added a carbon fiber rod in the wing for stiffness.
The high lift nature of this airfoil and somewhat over scale wing area combine to produce a slow flyer compared to most 1/12 scale fighters. However, this does provide extreme maneuverability without any trace of tip stall.
All in all it is a good flyer and is reasonably well suited for combat (provided the builder makes the needed changes to produce a more scale-like outline).
Dave West
P.S.
I did want to let you know of a couple of quality control problems in your kit packaging and shipping.
1. My kit arrived with the wrong plastic parts. I e-mailed you and you promptly sent me the correct parts—Thank you.
(OOPS!)
2. Some how, my order got duplicated, and I received (and was charged for) a second kit. (This one had the right parts). I was going to return it for a refund, but have decided that I will hang on to it - since the first one flew nicely.
(DOUBLE OOPS! Goes to show we aren't perfect however we strive to make all things right and would have promptly made a refund.) If the market is there we might make a few changes to incorporate Dave's ideas.
Side note: We have now made the changes Dave suggested plus, we have changed the wing so that it has a scale appearance. Click here to see it if you haven't already. 

 

Bruce has an excellent site, go to his site to check out his building procedures. http://rc.explosive.net

Bruce Forester sent us these photos and the following text. Take a good look at the nose of these planes and notice the size of the engines he has and then read on to find out the details. Some one at the Forester camp is very good with a graphics program too, the photo at the right is just the way it came to us through E-mail. Looks nice Bruce!

I have completed several of your kits and thought you might like hearing about them.

  The first Mustang (Yellow) has an O.S. 40LA on it. The only modifications that were made was to put a 1/4" balsa spar in the wing, top and bottom.

Also a rudder servo in the tail and I cut 1/2" off the nose. It flies great and has a long glide path at landing.

  The second Mustang (Red) had an MVVS 40 with tuned pipe and unfortunately did not fly. This was my fault not the fault of the plane.  I cut 1" off the nose and when I cut it off it must have not been straight.  This caused too much twist at take off.

  The Third Mustang (Blue) has the MVVS 40 with tuned pipe and it is so fast it is hard to describe.  This plane has to be "flown" all the time.  It's great fun and a real show stopper.  The modifications were to run the plastic former all the way to the tail for support, the 1/4" balsa wing spars and this time I didn't cut anything off the nose. This one also has rudder servo.

  The Fourth plane was your new Corsair, Blue) with an O.S. 46FX attached to the nose. It flies great and is very stable.  With an 11x7 prop it wants to leap out of your hand at launch.  It is very fast.  The modifications were to put 1/4" balsa spars top and bottom and mount the wing servos sideways for clearance.  This one has a rudder servo and a 40-70 adjustable mount so the engine can be moved farther forward.  I mounted the servo's in the tail.  They need to be much farther forward for balance.

  All planes were built with standard size servos and receivers. Another thing I like is the speed at which these planes can be built.  It cuts my building time by 70%.  Which is a good thing, as the cost of your planes being less than balsa kits has allowed me to have more planes. With these size engines, these planes are not for the faint of heart. Next summer, it is hoped that we will be flying combat with these planes.

Interest is growing at our club for these foam speedsters. I have one Mustang and one Corsair that I haven't built yet.  When they are done I will let you know what happens. I sent along some pictures I thought you might enjoy.

  Sincerely , Bruce Forester

This is a note from Bruce about a 60 powered Corsair he just built.....

The weather broke for a day that I was off, so I took out your Corsair that I put an O.S.61FX on to see what might happen. This plane is so cool it is hard to describe. Take off, or throw if you will, was flat, level, and fast. Like it was on a string. If it wasn't so fast a person could get in a chuckle or two. However, one must concentrate as it is fast, fast, fast. The really surprising thing is how stable the plane is. We tried to get it to snap, it just won't. The speed is just awesome and the rolls happen in less than a blink. A couple of us traded off flying as everyone watched what was going to happen. The flight was great, fast, and stable, then it was time to land. Power was turned off or it just died I'm not sure. Anyway, because of the altitude it was just glided around for awhile to bleed off the speed. No power and the plane just didn't seem to care, again it was very stable. It was lined up for landing and never faltered all the way to the ground. Just leveled it off about a foot off the ground and let it glide until it was time to set it down. No problems of any kind. If you look close on the fuselage you can see your company name on the side. The decals are home made on our computer and then printed on photo grade paper. Then they are taped with clear packing tape to the plane. This works really good and gives unlimited potential. Hope you enjoy the picture. Keep up the good work, you are making me look real good at the field.

Sincerely,

Bruce Forester

 

These plane started out as P51s

These are how some of our kits end up. Larry Brown built these from our P51 kit, he writes (about the low wing): A 450 Turbo, APC 7-5, and seven 700mah cells bring the weight to 36ozs. Not overpowered and not underpowered; it flies in scale. BEAUTIFUL! High speed low passes stop conversations and the soft, Ferrari like sound turns heads ..... He went on to tell a little about the bi-plane and an unfortunate demise. However, I believe he intends to make these available in a ready to fly plane so if your interested, give Larry a call at:

Air Show RC Flight Products

3960 W Pt. Loma Blvd   #H-435

San Diego, CA  92110    or call at:  619 222 4337